Thursday, February 12, 2009

V-Day = D-Day

This is a very relevant article written by my aunt. She was a Supreme court lawyer and has worked for years with NGO's.


Laws of Manu ( Manusmriti) is the basic foundation of Hindu law and his laws governed the ancient Hindu society.

Manusmriti belongs to period later than that of Vedas, written any time between 200BCE and 200CE. Manu was a man. His laws govern the status of women in Hindu society in all aspects, from her birth up to her death.

Under Manu's laws women were like chattel with not rights whatsoever.From time of her birth, she was considered 'paraya dhan' that is someone else's property. She had no place in the family of her birth.

As a girl, she was controlled by her father and brother. After marriage she was under the control of her husband and in-laws.

So a Hindu female was never born free. Even in her death she depended on man to light her funeral pyre without which she would be unable to attend 'Moksha', liberation of her soul.

Thus in India it is mandatory that women's relationship with men are expressed only through religious, ritualistic rites as per ancient Hindu law.

For example 'Bhaidooj,' Karwachouth', 'Vatsavitri' etc. are religious occasions where women worship and idolize their brothers and husbands as their protectors. These rites are intended to pump up male chauvinism. Also this religious rigidity is a pointer to the suspicious nature of our men folk vis-à-vis women and also other men. Result is men-women relationship tends to be frigid.

Since women are chattel, men are protective about their herd and any outside women is treated as an object of sex. This is so because in the world I would rank Indian men as most hyperactive sexually. Our ever-growing population explosion is a clear proof of it.

Where the religion sanctions such hypocritical, prudish attitude and double standards towards sex , there can only breed a society where there is no room for a healthy, friendly relationship between the opposite sexes.

Valentines's day is celebrated in memory of St. Valentine, an early Italian priest regarded as the patron of lovers. Feast day is 14th February.

Going by dictionary meaning, 'Love' is an intense feeling of deep affection or fondness. Love also means sexual passion or excitement. The Manuvadis understand only the later part of the meaning. If they wider their horizons, they will understand that sentiment of love has depth and purity and if treated with respect, it can only grow and spread.

Since last few years , in India the youngsters have started celebrating this benign festival of the West. In fact it gives a pleasant opportunity to young people to express their love and affection to the opposite sex. Taken in the right spirit, It should be considered as an harmless outlet of feelings which are otherwise suppressed and tabooed in our orthodox society.

One is amazed at the vicious reaction of groups like VHP, Bajrang Dal etc towards this innocuous revellery of youngsters.

In Bhopal, probably six years ago, a brother murdered his sister for giving a Valentine's card to her boyfriend The murderer was made into a hero by VHP and Bajrang Dal.

As reported by Times of India( 13th Feb.2004)In Gujrath, Bijal Joshi was made Vishva Hindu Parishad's poster girl for Valentine's day.

Bijal Joshi was raped and murdered by her lover. The members of Dura Vahini, women's wing of VHP decided to use the case of Joshi to create awareness and induce fear among V-Day revellers and to stop children from "corrupting influence of western culture which is manifesting itself in gang rapes"

Have these rabid ranters any idea about the rapes committed everyday in India inside bedrooms between married couples, mass rapes on dalit women, who are so poor that their huts do not have doors. Rapes committed on minor girls.

Does VHP, Bajrang Dal, Durga Vahini know how many women and minor girls are forced into flesh trade and repeatedly raped in a single day. Has VHP or Bajrang Dal done any constructive study in this field?

Another reason given by VHP etc. to oppose V-Day is " vulgarity depicted on V-cards"

Thus one can conclude that VHP et al will protect India from vulgarity, obscenity, rapes and murders of Western culture only on 14th February. It also follows that 'love' is a dirty word for them only

on 14th Feb. What happens rest of the time is not their concern.

It is unfortunate that depraved depiction of love in films, TV channels, pornographic website and literature etc is truly corrupting the minds of youth which is the real issue which should be addressed on a national level. In a male dominated society like ours, projection of women as sex symbols by mass communication systems , are making Indian women more vulnerable to the lust of sexually hyperactive but socially suppressed Indian males.

There are sporadic violent reactions by some bigots on non-issues only adding injury to our already fractured society.

Goddesses are worshipped only in temples. In real life Indian women by and large do not have any civil rights and liberties. In India where fifty percent population (women)is treated without equality, any respect, any care and who are under perpetual fear of abuse, is a pathetic blemish on the world's largest democracy.

No political party considers this as a very serious issue which needs to be considered on priority basis if India has to become a civil and just society.

Only those societies are strong and confident in whose social fabric liberties- civil and religious have been developed side by side with the growth of individual character in all classes of the nation.

Ranjana Bobde



Athena said...

Very well explained & expressed. It is unfortunate that vested interests have found Valentine's Day to harass women. I hope all the young women of India unite and teach these anti social elements a lesson they will not forget in a hurry.

Bhavya Shivaprakash said...

Beautifully written!
im sure theres no man who would disagree with what Manu had to say .. its so well crafted to suit his needs.

Anonymous said...

Your post is funny at best. I am sorry to say this, but it cracks me up when someone who is "Indian" just in name tries to give social commentary about India. Ask someone who has grown up in India.

And ya, before you dish out your translation of Vedas, it would actually help to really read some of those "books".

And do mind it, I am not saying things are perfect. It is not. It is not even perfect at the place where you think you are from. But I think you should keep all the "great" words to yourself, specially when you have no freaking idea what you are taking about. It would be ok if some White person wrote this, but for you I have one line "Shame on You".

Amrita said...

Dear Anonymous troll,
first off if you want to be derogatory on my blog at least have the decency to leave your name. Secondly, before you go dishing out your opinion on whether or I am Indian I would like you to read the entire post - it was not written by me.
Finally, whether or not anyone has grown up in India is immaterial when one is talking about the ill treatment of women and fanaticism.

Amrita said...

Incidentally, troll, why would it be OK if some 'white person' wrote this? Does the colour of the skin determine whether or not a person has the right to ' give social commentary about India'

Nandini said...

Dear anonymous,
Kindly get your facts right before jumping to conclusions. It was clearly stated at the end of the "social commentary" as you call it, that it was written by someone else, who by the way, has lived in India for 59 years, so
knows exactly what goes on there!

Oh and according to Article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, everybody has the right to hold opinions without interference, so please don't post things like "keep all the great words to yourself", especially on a blog!!!

Athena said...

Dear Anonymous,
your anonymity is limited only by the lack of a name. You are obviously a coward and have no respect for other humans. You are a shame for an Indian, i presume you are one as you have written with so much authority on the subject.Why don't you do yourself a favour - keep your uninformed,unsubstantiated,unsupported,inaccurate,and contentious comments to your self.